It is easy to love the people who already love us back. A child, a partner, an old friend — the warmth flows without effort, because it is met with warmth. The harder question is what happens to that same warmth when we picture someone who has hurt us. For most of us, it simply stops. We can be endlessly kind in one direction and quietly closed in the other, and never notice the wall, because nobody makes us stand in front of it on an ordinary day.
Buddhist practice has a name for the warmth itself, before it gets directed anywhere: the mind of loving-kindness. And it makes a claim that sounds almost like a technical instruction rather than a moral one — this mind has to be full before it can be spread. Not felt in theory. Full, the way a cup has to be full before it can overflow into anything else.
Photo by Brittany Lee on Unsplash
⁂
The Buddha’s teaching on this is old and specific. In the Karaniya Metta Sutta (Sutta Nipata 1.8, “Good Will” in Thanissaro Bhikkhu’s translation), he describes a person skilled in what is good who wants to attain peace: upright, content, gentle, and free of hostility. The sutta asks that one cultivate a limitless heart toward all beings, in the way a mother would protect her only child even at the cost of her own life, extending goodwill above, below and all around, without obstruction, whether beings are seen or unseen, near or far, already born or still seeking birth. According to the traditional commentary, the discourse was given when monks who had gone into a forest to meditate were so unsettled by what they met there that they returned to the Buddha for help. The sutta itself does not tell that story, which comes from later tradition.
What is easy to miss in that image is the fullness it implies. A mother’s love for her child is not a performance aimed outward first; it is something that fills her completely before it reaches anyone else. The sutta itself does not lay out a sequence of people to include. Later practice manuals, such as Buddhaghosa’s Visuddhimagga, teach the now-familiar order of beginning with oneself, then someone dear, then a neutral person, then someone difficult, and only then widening to all beings. Whatever the order, the point is the same: love has to be real before it can be that big.
⁂
This is also where the practice stops being comfortable. The most demanding form of it — arguably the whole point of it — is spreading that same loving-kindness toward the people who have hurt us, the ones we’ve quietly filed away as enemies. It is not difficult to love someone who has never cost us anything. It is a different order of practice to wish someone well who wronged us, and mean it, and want them to actually be released from whatever made them do it.
Because that is usually the missing piece: the person who hurt us was rarely acting from strength. More often it is someone unloved, mistaken, straining under a life that has already worn them down — and it is precisely that condition that produced the harm. Seen this way, anger at them starts to look less like justice and more like a refusal to look closely. We tend to place the entire cause of our suffering outside ourselves, in what they did, without asking what in us is still gripping onto it, still replaying it, still calling it unfinished. The other person’s actions happened once. Our holding onto them is a choice we keep renewing.
Photo by Arlind Photography on Unsplash
⁂
Is there evidence that wishing others well changes anything? Two studies give a careful yes. In a 2008 paper in the journal Emotion (volume 8, pages 720–724), Cendri Hutcherson, Emma Seppala and James Gross at Stanford University tested a brief loving-kindness meditation, lasting only a few minutes, against a closely matched control task. Compared with the control task, the meditation increased participants’ feelings of connection and positivity toward people they had just encountered, on both self-report measures and implicit measures of automatic responses. The abstract does not give details of the sample, and the effects were measured immediately, so we cannot say how long they last.
A longer study, by Barbara Fredrickson and colleagues in the Journal of Personality and Social Psychology in 2008 (volume 95, pages 1045–1062), randomly assigned 139 employees to a seven-week loving-kindness workshop, with six 60-minute group sessions and home practice at least five days a week, or to a waitlist. The meditation group’s daily positive emotions rose over the following weeks, and those gains were linked to increases in personal resources, such as purpose in life, self-acceptance and social support, which in turn predicted higher life satisfaction and fewer depressive symptoms about two weeks after the workshop. The authors note that the sample was mostly white and educated, that most measures were self-reported, and that the study cannot tell us whether the benefits last. Neither study tested the hardest case, wishing well to someone who has truly harmed you, so what they show is the general direction, not a guarantee.
None of this is only about other people, in the end. Loving-kindness turns out to be less a gift we hand outward and more a fire we keep lit in ourselves — an energy strong enough to pull us back out when we’ve sunk into our own difficulties, because a mind occupied with wishing others well has less room left to drown in its own grievances. It costs nothing to notice that the people who manage to hold onto this practice, even imperfectly, tend to be the ones who seem lightest — not because life has spared them, but because they’ve stopped carrying quite so much of it as a grudge.
❈
The Buddha’s own summary of why this matters is short. In the Dhammapada, verse 5, in Acharya Buddharakkhita’s translation, he says that resentment is never calmed by more resentment in this world and fades only through its opposite, goodwill. It is easy to nod at that and hard to apply it at the moment when someone has just been unfair to us. That is why the practice is built to be repeated in calm moments, so that when a hard moment arrives, the direction of the heart is already a little familiar. The same verse sits behind our reflection on preventing a third world war, which asks what it would take to apply it at the scale of nations.
Notice, too, that the practice asks very little at first. A single sincere sentence offered to one person, once a day, is a real beginning. Over weeks you may find that the circle you can include slowly grows, not because you forced it but because the habit of goodwill has become easier than the habit of grievance. If it does not, that is also information, and you can return to the easier steps without any sense of failure.
If you would like to try this, a simple version takes five minutes. Sit comfortably and take a few slow breaths. Bring to mind someone who is easy to care about, and silently offer phrases such as “may you be safe, may you be well, may you be at ease.” Then offer the same phrases to yourself, to a neutral person such as a neighbor or cashier, and finally, if it feels possible, to someone who has caused you difficulty. If that last step is too much, begin with someone mildly annoying and not with the person who hurt you most. There is no need to force a feeling of warmth; the intention itself is the practice. Many people find it easiest at the end of the day, as described in our guide to an evening wind-down routine.
It is also important to say that wishing someone well does not mean excusing what they did, reconciling with them, or staying in contact with someone who is unsafe. Forgiveness in this sense is an inner release, not a return to harm. And for some people, especially those carrying grief or trauma, this practice can stir up painful feelings. If that happens, it is fine to stop, to shorten the session or to talk with a trusted person or therapist. For a related reflection on love as something we build over time, see Love Is a Process of Investment.
So the practice is not really “love your enemies” as a slogan to admire from a distance. It is closer to a question you get to answer again each time it comes up: the next time you picture the person who hurt you most, do you still have the fullness to wish them, honestly, a way out of whatever made them do it — or is the wall still doing its work?
A note on this article: “Spreading the Mind of Loving-Kindness” is inspired by and draws lessons from a chapter in Chat with the Afterworld by author TG Minh Thạnh, translated from the original Vietnamese. Among the many themes explored across the book, this chapter focuses on the practice of loving-kindness — including toward those who have caused us harm — as a source of inner peace.













